Real vs Fake Apologies: 8 Red Flags

Real vs. Fake Apologies: 8 Red Flags

How do you know if an apology is truly sincere? In this episode, Matt and Erin walk through practical ways to evaluate an apology and respond in a way that protects the relationship and your peace.

What you’ll learn
• The difference between “I’m sorry” and sincere contrition
• 8 signs to watch for:
      1.Convenient timing (ulterior motives)
      2.Vague language (no specific action owned)
      3.Defensive tone or anger
      4.Over-explaining to self-justify
      5.Minimizing your hurt (“it’s not a big deal”)
      6.Blame-shifting (“sorry you were offended”)
      7.Sorry about consequences, not the harm
      8.No follow-through—or pressuring you to “get over it”
• How temperament and ignorance vs. contrition affect sincerity
• Mercy without enabling: requests, boundaries, and next steps
• Simple questions that draw out sincerity:
   - “What exactly are you sorry for?”
   - “How do you wish you’d acted?”
   - “What will you do differently next time?”

Key idea: Be a model of mercy while staying in your locus of control. You can forgive, ask for clarity, and set timelines for rebuilding trust—without accepting manipulation.

Related episode: How to Make a Sincere Apology (pairs perfectly with this one)

If this helped, share it with someone who needs a clear, faith-rooted framework for reconciliation.

Send us a text

Support the show

____________________

► Make sure to SUBSCRIBE to the Metanoia Catholic YouTube Channel!

► Find out your temperament: Take the Free Quiz

► Take the Quiz: WHAT TYPE OF COACH ARE YOU?

► GET THE DAILY SEVEN JOURNAL!
This interactive journal will help you transform your life from the inside out by teaching you how to grow in gratitude, set healthy goals, and gain mastery over your thoughts.

► JOIN THE ACADEMY!
Your online resource of classes, tools, and community to ramp up your growth and really change your life. Learn from the Metanoia Catholic coaches in webinars, live coaching calls, Lectio Divina, and more with your monthly membership.
____________________

► SUBSCRIBE TO THE CATHOLIC COACHING PODCAST
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
YouTube
Amazon Music
Castbox
Stitcher
____________________